Savoring the Locally Owned Flavor of Iowa City Area: Top 10 Restaurants

Welcome to the Iowa City area, where the culinary scene is as vibrant as the arts and culture surrounding it! Forget chain restaurants—here, we celebrate the uniqueness of our local flavors.

Communities
March 13, 2025
by Maria McCaw
by Sara Marshall of GreenState Credit Union

Welcome to the Iowa City area, where the culinary scene is as vibrant as the arts and culture surrounding it! Our charming Midwestern town is a food lover's paradise, brimming with locally owned restaurants serving high-quality dishes made with love and creativity. Forget chain restaurants—here, we celebrate the uniqueness of our local flavors. Buckle up your taste buds as we take you on a delicious journey through the top 10 must-visit eateries in Iowa City! Let’s dive into what makes these spots a must-visit for anyone seeking an authentic local dining experience.

1. Orchard Green

Step into Orchard Green, a delightful farm-to-table restaurant tucked away in a historic building. Here, the menu changes with the seasons, ensuring every bite is fresh and flavorful. Don’t miss their stunning roasted beet salad with goat cheese—it's a colorful explosion of taste that will make your palate sing! If you are looking for a low-key vibe check out the basement dining…it seems to be a favorite!

2. Pagliai's Pizza

Calling all pizza lovers! Pagliai's Pizza is a legendary spot that has been serving up mouthwatering pies since 1957. Known for its impossibly thin crust and generous toppings, this family-owned pizzeria is the perfect place to gather with friends and family. Be sure to try their famous “Palace Special” pizza, loaded with everything delicious—it's a slice of heaven!

3. 30 Hop

If you want great food with a view, 30 Hop is your ticket to deliciousness! This trendy spot features a menu packed with locally sourced ingredients and a fantastic selection of craft beers and cocktails. A guarantee to find an amazing match to your palette.

4. Bluebird Diner

Welcome to Bluebird Diner, where comfort meets creativity! This charming eatery serves up seasonal dishes that will leave you wanting more. The warm and inviting decor makes it a cozy spot for date night or brunch with friends. Don’t miss their fluffy buttermilk pancakes or the roasted vegetable risotto that will have you swooning!

5. Mirabito’s

Located in the heart of North Liberty, Mirabito’s is a beloved establishment known for its warm, welcoming atmosphere and a menu that celebrates the essence of Italian comfort food.  The restaurant is a go-to spot for locals.

6. Cortado

For coffee enthusiasts and brunch lovers alike, Cortado is an absolute gem. This cozy café is renowned for its artisanal coffee, crafted with precision and passion. The inviting atmosphere makes it the perfect spot to unwind with a good book or catch up with friends. Don’t miss out on their signature avocado toast and hearty breakfast burritos—each bite is a delightful start to your day! Whether you're in for a quick coffee or a leisurely brunch, Cortado is sure to impress.

7. Vesta

Vesta brings a taste of the Mediterranean to Iowa City with its vibrant menu that celebrates fresh ingredients and bold flavors. This charming restaurant offers an array of delectable small plates perfect for sharing, along with wood-fired pizzas that are simply irresistible. The warm, welcoming ambiance makes it an ideal spot for date nights or gatherings with friends.

8. Big Grove Brewery

Craft beer lovers, rejoice! Big Grove Brewery is the place to be for freshly brewed beers that perfectly complement a delicious menu of locally sourced dishes. The lively atmosphere, complete with outdoor seating, invites you to relax and enjoy good food and great company. With a rotating selection of seasonal brews and hearty food, Big Grove is a must-visit for anyone looking to unwind in style.

9. Pullman Bar & Diner

Step into Pullman Bar & Diner, where nostalgia meets modern flair! This fun diner is known for its creative brunches and quirky decor. Grab a seat and dig into their “Diner Burger”—it’s a mouthwatering experience that brings the best of Americana straight to your plate!

10. La Regia Taqueria

If you’re craving authentic Mexican cuisine, look no further than La Regia Taqueria. This beloved local spot is known for its flavorful tacos, burritos, and tortas, all made with fresh ingredients and traditional recipes. The vibrant decor and friendly service create a welcoming atmosphere that feels like home. La Regia is the perfect place to indulge in delicious food!

Maria McCaw profile picture

Meet Maria

Hello and welcome! As a proud member of this community and a dedicated Realtor, I’ve had the pleasure of helping many newcomers find their perfect home in the Iowa City area. It truly brings me joy to assist my clients on their journey. If you ever have any questions about the local area, real estate options, neighborhoods, recreational activities, or anything else, don’t hesitate to send me a message! I promise to respond promptly!

Meet Sara Marshall

Vice Present/Mortgage Loan Officer for GreenState Credit Union